Can one call oneself a Gorean without knowing the Gor books? This question returns from time to time like a boomerang, in various places and contexts. I used to think the answer was yes. Today, personally, I think it is no. I am, however, able to accept an affirmative answer, though with certain – very important – reservations. The issue is, in fact, quite complex.
People draw their knowledge from different sources, and those sources can vary in quality. They may be valuable or completely inadequate. They may be factual and substantive, or – on the contrary – distort the spirit of Gorean philosophy, manipulate it. Not everyone is able to read the Chronicles of Gor in English. Not everyone, even today, knows the language well enough to read sci-fi or fantasy literature comfortably. I myself struggled with this for a long time. The Gor Chronicles were never published in Polish, so at the beginning I drew my knowledge from other, available and more accessible sources. Later I began to read them, but in French editions, because I feel much more comfortable in this language than in English.
Returning to the main question: can someone say of themselves that they are a Gorean if their knowledge of Gor comes from sources other than direct reading of John Norman’s books? In my opinion, no. Or rather: technically, they can. Because no one can forbid them from doing so. But I consider it dishonest and indicative of a lack of understanding of the philosophy. I will explain why.
Gorean Lifestyle functions (especially in primary circles, that is, American communities) as a secondary culture: a living interpretive tradition transmitted through communities, discussions, mentoring, relational practice, observation, and the exchange of experience. However – and this is extremely important – it is, above all, a culture. Not merely a kink, which is what strongly distinguishes Gorean Lifestyle communities from other kinds of kink communities and other power-exchange dynamics. Contact with this culture can occur in various ways; nevertheless, recognition and acceptance of the cultural dimension are absolutely crucial for full identification with the Gorean Lifestyle. Because it is precisely philosophy and culture that largely constitute it, regardless of whether someone accepts that or not. This is not only about the Master–slave dynamic. That dynamic is just one of many dimensions of the entire Gorean subculture.
An initial encounter with the Gorean theme as such can take many forms: through a mention, in a discussion, reading someone's blog or post. Fascination may begin with the philosophy of roles, the depth of devotion, the ethics of responsibility, the symbolism of power and service in the Gorean context. Only later (or in parallel) does one reach for the source texts. The mere fact that someone has not yet read the books does not automatically make their stance "non-Gorean". The Gor Chronicles consist of several dozen volumes. It is also difficult to say that one must read all of them, or to set a quantitative threshold at which someone "acquires" the right to call themselves a Gorean – or not yet. I have known men who had no knowledge of Gor and yet embodied, in their attitude, almost all the ideals articulated by Gorean philosophy. Many practices they had always applied appear in the books – they were simply unaware of it, because they had never read them.
At the same time – precisely because this is a very clearly defined philosophy and culture – I deeply believe that without familiarity with the literary canon of Gor, it is difficult to speak of a full, conscious, and honest Gorean self-identification. At best, one can speak of being a sympathizer or of partial identification, but not a complete one. Not if one wishes to be honest toward others and toward oneself. How can someone who does not truly know this philosophy in its entirety, from its original source, but only secondhand, honestly say that they identify with it? How can one identify with something one does not, in essence, know? In my opinion – one cannot.
The books are not merely narrative background – they constitute a conceptual foundation: they define the language, hierarchies (both within the Master–slave relationship and on the community level), anthropological assumptions, the tensions and dependencies between nature and culture, between freedom and ownership, or between responsibility and power. Without them, it is easy to mistake the Gorean Lifestyle for general BDSM, power exchange, or an aesthetic "inspired by Gor". Alternatively –which I consider a major problem of the Polish kink environment – to assume that Gor is simply a "more advanced level of initiation" into BDSM.
The matter is complex, because it is not only about someone’s identification, but about its honesty, transparency, and authenticity – and about respect for Gorean culture. Ultimately, someone may function "in a Gorean way", in the Gorean spirit, and authentically live by these values, even if they know them secondhand. They may understand them in a way similar to how they are understood in the books, despite not having read the books themselves. They may live by them every day. Nevertheless, I still believe that reading the books is indispensable if someone wants, in full honesty, to claim that they understand Gor and feel that they are a Gorean. Because Gorean is not merely books about a fictional planet. It is a very coherent philosophy, not merely a collection of borrowed motifs or an alternative form of kink. And although many paths may lead into this world, full understanding requires a return to the source. And the source is the books.